Apple and Fortnite maker Epic trade blows as antitrust court battle begins – CNET

This site is reader-supported. When you click through links on our site, we may be compensated.

gettyimages-1232312151
Apple and the company behind Fortnite are in an epic battle antitrust. (Get used to these jokes)


Getty Images

                                                                                                            <p class="speakableTextP1"><a href="https://www.cnet.com/apple/" data-annotation="true" data-component="linkTracker" data-link-tracker-options="{&quot;action&quot;:&quot;inline-annotation|Apple|CNET_TAG|823&quot;}" section="annotation">Apple</a> and Epic, the developer behind the hit game <span data-error="was unable to determine path for annotation" data-annotation-type="CNET_FAM_SERIES">Fortnite</span>, began arguments in a California courtroom Monday for their high profile <span class="link" section="shortcodeLink"><a href="https://www.cnet.com/news/apple-battle-fortnite-could-change-iphone-as-we-know-it/">antitrust lawsuit over the future of the iPhone and iPad App Store</a></span>. In their opening statements, the two companies dueled over Apple's policies, and whether its notoriously tight control over its devices constitutes a monopoly.&nbsp;</p><p class="speakableTextP2">Epic argued <span class="link" section="shortcodeLink"><a href="https://www.cnet.com/news/google-and-apple-grilled-on-app-store-policies-in-tense-senate-hearing/">Apple's App Store policies</a></span>, which require that developers submit <a href="https://www.cnet.com/tags/apps/" data-annotation="true" data-component="linkTracker" data-link-tracker-options="{&quot;action&quot;:&quot;inline-annotation|apps|CNET_TAG|183&quot;}" section="annotation">apps</a> to Apple for review before they can be sold or given away for free, was unnecessary. Epic also said the up to 30% commission Apple charges on some purchases of items in apps, such as a new look for a Fortnite character, raises costs on iPhone and iPad owners and locks them into its system.




<div class="c-reengageNewsletter shortcode hasNewsletter newsletter-subscribe-form desktop broad" data-component="newsletterAndInterest" data-newsletter-and-interest-options="{&quot;id&quot;:&quot;d1753851-e519-4744-897e-9b6ea3b1c04b&quot;,&quot;name&quot;:&quot;MOBILE&quot;,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;broad&quot;,&quot;description&quot;:&quot;Cell Phones&quot;,&quot;ecode&quot;:&quot;e723&quot;,&quot;isBroadInterest&quot;:true,&quot;hasNotifTextHed&quot;:&quot;For more like this&quot;,&quot;hasNotifTextDek&quot;:&quot;Subscribe to the Mobile newsletter, receive notifications and see related stories on CNET.&quot;}" readability="7">
    <h5 data-reengage-hed="null">Cut through the chatter</h5>
    Subscribe to CNET's Mobile newsletter for the latest phone news and reviews.

</div>

“Epic is not suing for damages,” one of Epic’s lawyers said. “Epic is suing for change, not just for itself, but for all developers.”

Apple pushed back, saying its App Store has helped fuel new multi billion dollar companies. “Epic speculates about a world where Apple is a different company,” Apple argued. “It’s asking the court to make a big bet that world is a better world than the one we live in. It’s not.”

The fiery speeches from both companies kicked off what may be one of the most important antitrust lawsuits in years. Apple’s iPhone is one of the most popular consumer products ever made, with more than 1 billion of them being used today. That success has helped grow Apple’s business to more than $274.5 billion last year, with Wall Street valuing it at more than $2 trillion. But Epic argues Apple’s success has come in part because of how it treats competitors on its devices, handicapping them while giving itself preferential treatment.

On its surface, the lawsuit looks like a quarrel between a multibillion dollar company and a two-trillion dollar company about who gets how much money when we all buy stuff in apps. But the outcome of this case could change everything we know about Apple’s App Store, and about how mobile transactions work on other platforms like the Google Play store as well. It could also invite further scrutiny from lawmakers, who are already debating whether tech giants like Apple and Google wield too much power.

    <div class="shortcode video v2" data-video-playlist="[{&quot;id&quot;:&quot;847add88-e303-43c0-9dd6-94d232f3d854&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;Epic Games v. Apple: Trial preview&quot;,&quot;description&quot;:&quot;One of techu0027s biggest antitrust trials is about to begin; hereu0027s what to expect.&quot;,&quot;slug&quot;:&quot;epic-games-v-apple-trial-preview&quot;,&quot;chapters&quot;:{&quot;data&quot;:[],&quot;paging&quot;:{&quot;total&quot;:0,&quot;limit&quot;:15,&quot;offset&quot;:0}},&quot;datePublished&quot;:&quot;2021-04-30 13:00:03&quot;,&quot;duration&quot;:407,&quot;mpxRefId&quot;:&quot;rzVKMCcTc_qKR_Xsc5UXv_FYOYrMs0nS&quot;,&quot;ratingVChip&quot;:&quot;TV-14&quot;,&quot;primaryTopic&quot;:{&quot;id&quot;:&quot;1c7ebf90-c387-11e2-8208-0291187b029a&quot;},&quot;author&quot;:{&quot;id&quot;:&quot;b163284d-6b73-44fc-b3e6-3da66c392d40&quot;,&quot;firstName&quot;:&quot;Ashley&quot;,&quot;lastName&quot;:&quot;Esqueda&quot;},&quot;primaryCollection&quot;:{&quot;id&quot;:&quot;040fa0bc-bf08-43dc-ac3d-ee7869a9fc85&quot;,&quot;title&quot;:&quot;CNET News Video&quot;},&quot;image&quot;:{&quot;path&quot;:&quot;https://www.cnet.com/a/img/WVhLwCXaDganLwh3pOVIo6ubWOI=/1280x720/2021/04/29/6a7b4fa5-3688-48ef-8d29-b643910d17ea/apple-v-epic-recap-thumb.jpg"},"thumbnail":"https://www.cnet.com/a/img/6YJTo4Qa9FLEblA8t_4SLXvwxaI=/194x109/2021/04/29/6a7b4fa5-3688-48ef-8d29-b643910d17ea/apple-v-epic-recap-thumb.jpg","closedCaptionPath":"/videos/captions/webvtt/epic-games-v-apple-trial-preview.vtt","urlPath":"/videos/epic-games-v-apple-trial-preview/","isVertical":false,"m3u8":"https://cnetvideo.cbsistatic.com/vr/2021/04/29/1891643971980/649774_hls/master.m3u8","mp4":"https://cnetvideo.cbsistatic.com/vr/2021/04/29/1891643971980/AppleVEpicRecap-3_649773_740.mp4","index":0}]" readability="6">
        <div class="embeddedVideoContainer" tabindex="0" aria-label="Play video Epic Games v. Apple: Trial preview" data-load-video="0" data-video-id="847add88-e303-43c0-9dd6-94d232f3d854" readability="7">
            <div class="videoContainer">
                <svg class=" play">
<use aria-hidden="false" xlink:href="#play" />

                <svg class=" pause">
<use aria-hidden="false" xlink:href="#pause" />

                                        <figure class=" img"><img src="https://scoreit.online/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/apple-and-fortnite-maker-epic-trade-blows-as-antitrust-court-battle-begins" data-original="https://scoreit.online/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/apple-v-epic-recap-thumb-1.jpg" class="photo lazy" alt height="110" width="196"><noscript><img src="https://scoreit.online/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/apple-v-epic-recap-thumb-1.jpg" class="photo" alt height="110" width="196"></noscript></figure>
                                </div>
            <p>
                <span class="bold">
                    <span class="nowPlaying">Now playing:</span>
                    <span class="watchThis">Watch this:</span>
                </span>
                Epic Games v. Apple: Trial preview


                <span class="duration">
                    <svg class=" video">
<use aria-hidden="false" xlink:href="#video" />


6:47

        </div>
    </div>
The companies are arguing before a California judge in what's called a bench trial, meaning there is no jury. This allows the companies to plead their cases without having to educate and then sway a jury, setting up an easier appeals process when a decision is handed down.&nbsp;

The nature of a bench trial also means both companies will likely dig into the weeds of their arguments, tussling over theories that could inform antitrust debates for years to come.

“Epic’s antitrust lawsuit threatens the billions of dollars in revenue the App Store generates,” Jennifer Rie, a litigation analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence, wrote in recent research report. But Apple’s argument that its approach protects the security and privacy of users will weigh heavily on the proceedings, she added. “We’re skeptical that Epic will prevail in the long term.”

Although Epic says allowing competing App Stores and payment processing on iPhones would lower prices and foster competition, Apple said it would need to find new ways to recoup the development and operation costs for its App Store. 

“Apple would still be entitled to collect a commission and developers would have to pay extra for services Apple now covers,” Apple argued. “The cost could be passed down to consumers, which will also create more friction from a transaction, which in turn will be bad for developers.”

Epic’s lawsuit against Apple is began Monday, May 3 and is expected to run for several weeks. The audio of the in-person courtroom proceedings will be carried live over a teleconference, and chosen pool reporters will be in the room. 

CNET will be covering the proceedings live, just as we always do — by providing real-time updates, commentary and analysis you can get only here.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.